Faber vs Alfred: which piano method book to choose
Neither series is better for everyone. Faber's Piano Adventures is usually described as faster and more focused on expressive playing, technique and creative work from the start, which suits a keen child of about seven or older, a self-taught adult, or a teacher who wants theory and improvisation built in. Alfred's Basic Piano Library is usually described as steadier and more traditional, with familiar tunes and plenty of review, which suits an average young beginner or a student who needs more repetition. Both publishers also make separate courses for very young children and for adults, so the right comparison depends on who is learning.
Last updated 17 November 2026. Series facts from the publishers' pages for Piano Adventures, Basic Piano Adventures, Alfred's Basic Piano Library and Alfred's Premier Piano Course. Teaching opinions from reviews by Marisa E. Cardin at Ensemble Performing Arts and Huitzu Lin. All read on that date. We make PianGo, a free practice app; we don't sell or include either series.
The short answer
Faber for pace and musicianship, Alfred for steady repetition. Cardin's review says Piano Adventures moves "at a moderate to slightly faster pace" than Alfred and puts a stronger emphasis on expressive playing, while Alfred leans on traditional notation and familiar tunes. Lin's review of methods for six- to eight-year-olds reaches a similar split from the other side: Alfred is well paced for an average young beginner, while Faber suits talented students or slightly older beginners and is too complicated for an average six-year-old. These are teachers' opinions, not tests, so look at a sample of each before buying a full set.
Faber and Alfred side by side
| Faber Piano Adventures | Alfred's Basic Piano Library | |
|---|---|---|
| Main course | Basic Piano Adventures: 8 levels, Primer, 1, 2A, 2B, 3A, 3B, 4 and 5, "Beginning to Intermediate" | Basic Course: Lesson Books 1A, 1B and 2 to 6 |
| Stated age | "Ages 6 and up" in the menu; "ages 6-11" in the course description | Not stated for the Basic Course |
| Youngest beginners | My First Piano Adventures, ages 5 to 6 (books A, B and C) | Prep Course, "five years and up" (books A to F) |
| Older beginners | Accelerated Piano Adventures, levels 1 and 2 | Complete Level 1, for students who start later than average; or the Premier Piano Express line |
| Adults | Adult Piano Adventures 1 and 2 | Adult courses (a separate collection) |
| Books per level | Lesson, Theory, Technique & Artistry, Performance and Sightreading (per Cardin) | Lesson, Theory, Technic and Recital; also an All-in-One Course that combines lesson, theory and solo |
| Reading | Multi-position; does not stay in five-finger positions (Lin) | Intervals of 2nds to 5ths (publisher); a multi-key approach built around positions (Lin) |
| Pace | Moderate to slightly faster than Alfred (Cardin); suits slightly older or talented beginners (Lin) | Steady, with review pages before new concepts (Lin) |
| Music | Folk songs, original pieces and simplified classical themes (Cardin) | Familiar tunes (Cardin, Lin); a lot of folk tunes (Lin) |
| Creative work | Theory, improvisation and composition in the curriculum (publisher) | No improvising, transposing or composing in the Basic Course (Lin) |
| Audio and video | Piano Adventures Player app for iPhone and iPad: three free songs per level, full library $4.99 per level; Audio Cloud streams on any device; video support for several books | Not listed on the Basic Library page. The Premier Piano Course has recordings at performance and slower practice tempos and correlated videos |
How the two series teach reading
This is the difference teachers argue about most. Alfred's own page says the Basic Course introduces "a quick way to learn to read by recognizing music intervals of 2nds, 3rds, 4ths, and 5ths." Lin describes it as a multi-key approach that moves through hand positions, and counts strong intervallic reading among its strengths but also says the position approach limits how much a child explores the keyboard by ear.
Faber, in Lin's description, is multi-position: it changes hand positions often rather than settling into a five-finger position, and it introduces form, sequences and transposition early. The cost, in Lin's view, is less repetition to reinforce each concept. Cardin adds that Piano Adventures introduces dynamics, phrasing and expression early, not after reading is secure.
If the reader is a child who finds note reading hard, the extra review in Alfred can help; if they already read quickly, Faber's variety may hold their interest longer. Either way, reading improves with practice outside the method book too. Our guides to reading piano sheet music and bass clef and ledger lines cover the notation both series teach.
Which series suits which learner
| Learner | Start with | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Age 5 | My First Piano Adventures or Alfred's Prep Course | Both are written for this age; the main Basic courses are not |
| Age 6, average pace | Alfred's Basic Course, Level 1A | Lin judges Faber too complicated for an average six-year-old and praises Alfred's pacing |
| Age 7 to 11, keen or quick | Basic Piano Adventures, Primer | Faber's stated range is 6 to 11; Lin says it suits slightly older or talented beginners |
| Child starting later than average | Faber Accelerated or Alfred Complete Level 1 | Both publishers have a course for older beginners |
| Teen or adult | Adult Piano Adventures, Alfred's adult courses or Premier Piano Express | Adult books skip the children's pacing; Premier Express is described as for "older beginners, teens, and adults" |
| Wants improvisation and composing | Faber | The publisher lists improvisation and composition; Lin says Alfred's Basic Course has none |
| Wants recognisable tunes | Alfred | Both reviews mention its familiar tunes |
If the question is when to start at all, see what age a child should start piano lessons, and for daily practice length how long a child should practise.
A checklist before you buy
- Ask the teacher first. Many teachers teach from one series, and switching mid-level means gaps.
- Pick the right course, not just the right brand. Within each publisher, the very-young, standard, older-beginner and adult courses are separate books.
- Look inside. Alfred offers a free Premier Piano Course sampler and a level comparison chart; sample pages for either series are worth seeing before you buy a full set.
- Start with the lesson book. The theory, technique and performance books are companions; you can add them once you know the series suits the student.
- Check the audio on your devices. Faber's Player app is for iPhone and iPad; on Android, its Audio Cloud website streams the same accompaniments.
- Don't switch at the first hard page. Both series get harder by design. Switch when the pace is consistently wrong, not after one tricky piece.
What about Alfred's Premier Piano Course?
Alfred publishes more than one method, and the newer Premier Piano Course is a separate series from the Basic Piano Library. Its page lists Lesson, Theory, Performance and Technique books correlated with each other, recordings on acoustic piano at both performance and slower practice tempos, and Online Assistant videos correlated to the page in the Lesson Book where each concept first appears. Its faster line, Premier Piano Express, uses a non-position reading approach built on landmark notes. So "Alfred" in a forum thread might mean either series; check which one before comparing it with Faber.
Where PianGo fits, and where it does not
We make PianGo, so to be clear: it is not a method. It has no curriculum and does not include Faber, Alfred or any other publisher's books, so it cannot replace a lesson book. What it does, from its code, is help with practising a piece once you have it as a MusicXML or MIDI file:
- It plans fingering for the whole piece and draws hands over the keys, keeping any fingering already in the file. Our fingering guide explains the numbers your method book prints.
- It waits for the right note in Learn it mode, so a child can work out a new piece without being rushed.
- It practises one hand at a time, loops a range of bars and sets the tempo.
It has 168 built-in pieces, including public-domain scores, which some students use for extra pieces at their level between lessons. It is free, runs in a browser and needs no account. For more free scores, see free MusicXML files for piano.
Common questions
Is Faber or Alfred better for beginners?
It depends on the beginner. Teacher reviews describe Faber as faster and more musically varied, suiting keen or slightly older children, and Alfred as steadier with more review and familiar tunes, suiting an average young beginner.
What age is Faber Piano Adventures for?
Basic Piano Adventures is listed for ages 6 and up, and its course page says ages 6 to 11. My First Piano Adventures is for ages 5 to 6, and there are separate Accelerated and Adult courses.
What levels does Alfred's Basic Piano Library have?
The Basic Course runs from Lesson Book 1A and 1B through Levels 2 to 6. Before it there is a Prep Course, books A to F, for children five and up.
Which is better for adults teaching themselves?
Both publishers make adult courses, Adult Piano Adventures and Alfred's adult books, plus Alfred's Premier Piano Express for older beginners. Faber's adult books have video support and play-along audio, which helps without a teacher.
Can you switch from Alfred to Faber?
Yes, but the levels don't line up exactly, and the two series introduce concepts in a different order. Ask a teacher to place the student, or start a level lower and move quickly through what they already know.
Practise the next piece key by key
Open a piece in PianGo, choose the hand, and it shows the key and the finger. Free, in the browser, with no account.