PianGo

Should you practise piano hands separately?

Yes, for the bars you cannot yet play with both hands, and no for the bars you can. Practise a short passage with each hand alone until it is accurate at a slow tempo, switching hands often, then put the hands together on that same passage straight away rather than finishing the whole piece one hand at a time. Teachers disagree about how much hands-separate work is worth, but they mostly agree on that much. This page sets out where they differ, when each approach fits, and a routine you can use tonight.

Last updated 11 November 2026. Teaching advice summarised from the sources linked in each section, read on that date. We make PianGo, a practice app with a one-hand mode, and say so where it comes up.

The short answer

Use hands-separate practice as a repair tool, not a stage you have to finish. Pick the two to four bars that break down, play the right hand alone, then the left hand alone, a few times each, slowly, with the fingering you will use in the end. As soon as each hand is accurate, join them at an even slower tempo. If a passage already works hands together, skip the separate step. Memorising, and passages where each hand has its own melody, are the two cases where extra separate work tends to pay off.

What piano teachers actually say

Search for this question and you find confident answers pointing in opposite directions. Three published positions show the range:

Three positions on hands-separate (HS) practice, from the sources linked, read 11 November 2026.
SourcePositionWhen to use HSDistinctive advice
Fundamentals of Piano Practice (free online book)HS is where technique is builtOnly for difficult passages you cannot play; skip it if hands together is adequateSwitch hands every 5 to 15 seconds; memorise everything HS
flowkey's guide to playing with both handsLearn each hand first, then combineFor each short section of a new pieceSections of about 4 to 8 seconds; practise the transitions between sections
Rebecca Bogart, piano teacherHands together usually winsIn some specific situations onlyFind the points where the hands line up; "think pairs, not isolated notes"

The disagreement is smaller than it looks. Nobody here argues for learning a whole piece one hand at a time and only then joining the hands. Fundamentals of Piano Practice says plainly that hands-separate work is for passages you cannot yet play, and that the goal is to need it less over time. Bogart calls separate practice "usually a waste of time" but still gives it a place. flowkey's version is the beginner-friendly middle: short sections, each hand, then both, then join the sections.

When hands separately helps, and when it does not

A rule of thumb for choosing, based on the positions above.
SituationHands separately?Why
A fast run or awkward stretch in one handYes, that handYou can fix the notes and fingering without also coordinating the other hand.
Each hand has its own melody (Bach, inventions, counterpoint)YesEach line needs to make sense on its own before the two can be balanced.
Memorising a pieceYesFundamentals of Piano Practice recommends memorising each hand separately.
The left hand keeps laggingYes, mostly leftThe bass clef and the weaker hand usually get less practice; give them more.
Melody over simple chords or a repeating patternBriefly, then togetherThe difficulty is how the hands fit, which you only practise with both.
A passage that already works hands togetherNoSeparate practice adds time and nothing else here.
The hands play in strict rhythm with each other (chords on the beat, a dance bass)Find the alignment points insteadBogart's approach: learn which notes land together.

A hands-separate routine for one hard passage

  1. 1. Choose two to four bars. The ones that break down, not the whole page. A few seconds of music, in flowkey's terms.
  2. 2. Settle the fingering first. Decide which finger plays each note and write it in, because changing it later means relearning. Our piano fingering guide has the rules.
  3. 3. Right hand alone, slowly, three or four times, until it is accurate without stopping.
  4. 4. Left hand alone, slowly, the same number of times or more. It is usually the weaker hand and reads the clef you have practised less; see how to read piano sheet music if bass clef notes are slow to name.
  5. 5. Switch back and forth. Short turns keep the resting hand fresh; Fundamentals of Piano Practice suggests switching every 5 to 15 seconds rather than drilling one hand until it tires.
  6. 6. Join the hands at a slower tempo than either hand alone. Coordination is a new skill, so expect it to feel harder than the separate versions.
  7. 7. Join the passage to the bar before it. flowkey's guide stresses practising the transitions between sections, which is where joined-up chunks often fall apart.
  8. 8. Raise the tempo only once hands together is accurate. If it breaks, go back one step, not all the way to the start.

This fits inside a normal practice session. Our page on learning piano with an app has a 20-minute session plan with eight minutes set aside for exactly this. For a passage that still breaks after this, how to practise a difficult passage covers shortening the loop, rhythm changes and leaps.

Mistakes that make hands-separate practice backfire

  • Finishing the whole piece one hand at a time. Joining the hands then becomes learning a third piece. Join each passage as soon as both hands can play it.
  • Different fingering alone and together. If a hand uses a convenient fingering alone that does not work with the other hand, you will practise the wrong habit. Use the final fingering from the first repetition.
  • Racing one hand. Getting the right hand up to full speed alone does not carry over when the left hand joins. Keep the separate tempo close to what you can manage together.
  • Only ever practising the right hand. The melody is more fun, so the left hand gets less time and lags behind. Give it the extra repetitions.
  • Doing it for passages that already work. Spend the time where the music breaks down.

Practising one hand at a time in PianGo

We make PianGo, so weigh this accordingly. Its practice settings have a "Which hands to practise" switch: Both hands, Right or Left. Choose one hand and PianGo waits only for that hand's notes, the drawn hand on the keyboard shows only that hand's fingering, and in play-along mode the piece keeps its rhythm, so the gaps where the other hand would play are still counted. You can loop the bars you are working on, slow the tempo, and switch back to both hands without leaving the piece, which is the routine above. It listens through the microphone at an acoustic piano or over MIDI in Chrome and Edge, plans fingering for the whole piece (keeping any printed in the file), and works with its 168 built-in pieces or your own MusicXML or MIDI file. It is free, runs in a browser, and practising needs no account.

What it cannot do: it does not judge your tone, balance between the hands, pedalling or posture, and it is not a teacher deciding which passages need the work. It checks which notes you played and when.

Common questions

Is it bad to practise piano hands separately?

Not in itself. It wastes time on passages you can already play hands together, and it backfires if you learn a whole piece one hand at a time before joining the hands. Used on short, difficult passages and joined up early, it is a standard technique.

How long should I practise each hand before putting them together?

Until each hand plays the passage accurately at a slow tempo, which for a short passage may be only a few repetitions. Then join the hands at an even slower tempo rather than polishing each hand further.

Should beginners learn hands separately first?

For new pieces, flowkey's beginner guide says yes, in short sections: each hand, then both, then join the sections. As reading and coordination improve, you need the separate step less often.

Why is my left hand so much harder?

For most people it is the weaker hand, and on the grand staff it reads the bass clef, which beginners practise less. Give it more of the separate repetitions, and drill bass clef note names away from the piano.

How do I get my hands to play together?

Work on a few bars at a time, slower than either hand alone, and find the notes where the hands land together. Practise the join into the next section too. Raise the tempo only once it is accurate.

Loop the hard bars, one hand at a time

Open PianGo, pick a piece, switch to Right or Left, and loop the bars that break down while it shows the fingering and waits for each note. Then switch to Both. Free, nothing to install.